Can we have a little more honesty about parenting, please? Yes, children are amazing and our love for them can be unbearable at times. But, so can our frustration.
Are we adequately prepared? Where’s our village? Anna Quindlen wonders the same:
So why is raising kids the most important job we ignore from a preparation point of view? Oh, there are more parenting classes and books than in the days when tutelage was mainly your mother saying, “You’ll spoil that child if you pick him up every time he cries.” A few high schools give their students a baby doll to carry around and tend, but that seems largely an attempt at libido suppression.
“Parenting is a much more separate, solitary activity than it used to be,” says Harold S. Koplewicz, the director of the NYU Child Study Center, where Brotman also works. It used to take a village to raise a child, but there isn’t a village anymore. Instead of extended family, there’s a playground where everyone pretends everything’s fine, and a computer screen behind which women can say, under cover of mommy blogs, “How come this is so hard for me?”
The prevailing ethos about being a parent is that it’s mostly intuitive and uniformly joyful, even though the news, and our own lives, are full of those who found it so conspicuously otherwise that they made an utter mess of actual human beings.
Read more here: Quindlen: Why Do We Pretend Parenting Is Easy? | Newsweek Voices – Anna Quindlen | Newsweek.com.
Do you relate to this? Do you put a different face on parenting in public? Do you feel isolated in your situation?
I think I’m pretty honest about my experience staying home with my kids. I am grateful to have the opportunity and love the depth of it all, but also feel like the famed Waffle House order: scattered, smothered, covered. It’s as if I’m wading through cement sometimes, being clawed at most of the time, and having my ear talked off all of the time.
I tend more toward feeling smothered than isolated, thanks to my strong support network (ra-ra to you all!). And, I assume most people are feeling a similar mix of emotions throughout a day or week or month, which is unifying rather than isolating for me.
So, about this pretending things are fine when they are not and then ranting behind a computer screen — I’m working on a theory here that involves a combination of our busy lifestyles and growing up during the self help movement . . .
Amen sister! I have often found some of my remarks about how hard things are/can be (with “aquaintance” friends and other moms I don’t know well yet) are met with a blank stare and frozen smiles, leaving me thinking… ooooh i have shared too much! I am so grateful for my support system of friends who can and do tell it like it is (you being tops dear one!), and in doing so help me do the same.
I recommend to my pre-natal yoga students, and try to give my new mom friends one of the following books which I have found can help break the ice on discussing the paradox of loving your child/ren more than anything, while also feeling like you might lose your mind. I found each of them helpful in encouraging my own honesty – to myself and to others – about my own daily up and down experience.
- Operating Instructions by Annie Lamont
- I Was a Really Good Mom Before I Had Kids by Trisha Ashworth and Amy Nobile
- Momma Zen by Karen Maezen Miller
- Waiting for Birdie by Catherine Newman
All are short and easy reads too… since as all moms know, time and concentration and in short supply!
Great site. I found you through Problogger’s forums. Will subscribe through reader and catch up. Stop on by if you get a chance. I write humor stories (mostly) about the Adventures of Mr. Busypants (he’s 6 and has mild autism) and his chunky sidekick, almost 2 Miss Chattyshoes. See ya around.
Yes yes yes..
This is so true. I have met the same blank stare that the reader Andrea mentions above.
I think that many of us have a sense of perfectionism towards parenting, combined with “information overload”. (So MANY books, sites, etc. telling us how to do it..) I think that this attitude (which many women don’t even realize they have..) contributes to post partum depression and anxiety, which I myself definitely experienced, and only realized later on. I have a lot more perspective now, and also realize that the baby times were not my own “zing” as a parent, (sorry if I’m not using the term correctly, but I like it!)
My sister got mad at me recently because she said I am “too negative” when we talk about parenting, having kids, etc. (and i should examine this, although of course I think she is wrong!) But she is in a very “idealistic” stage about it, (yeah! We’ve all been there as Moms!) I’m so excited for her to have kids, but I also want her to be more prepared than I was for how hard it can be..how I can do this without bursting her bubble I’m not sure.
I look forward to reading the full Anna Quindlen article!
Anna